When remodeling a bathroom, one of the biggest decisions is choosing between a walk-in shower and a bathtub. Each option has its own benefits and drawbacks, depending on space, lifestyle, and aesthetics. Let’s break down the key factors to consider when making the best choice for your home.
If your bathroom is on the smaller side, a walk-in shower can maximize space and make the room feel larger. Walk-in showers create an open, airy feel, often with seamless glass doors and minimal barriers. On the other hand, a bathtub takes up more floor space and can make a compact bathroom feel cramped. However, if space isn’t an issue, a freestanding tub can serve as a luxurious focal point in a spacious master bath.
For those with mobility concerns, walk-in showers are the safer choice. A low or no-threshold entry eliminates the need to step over a tub wall, reducing the risk of slipping. Many walk-in showers also include grab bars and built-in seating for extra stability. Bathtubs, while ideal for long soaks, can be difficult to enter and exit, making them less practical for aging homeowners or those with limited mobility.
Walk-in showers are easier to clean compared to bathtubs. With fewer crevices and minimal grout lines (especially if using large-format tiles or solid surfaces), a walk-in shower requires less scrubbing. Bathtubs, particularly alcove models, can be more challenging to clean due to the high walls and awkward angles that collect soap scum and mildew.
Showers generally use less water than filling a bathtub, making them the more eco-friendly option. A typical shower uses about 2.1 gallons per minute, meaning a 10-minute shower consumes roughly 21 gallons. In contrast, an average bathtub requires 40–50 gallons per use. If sustainability and lower water bills are priorities, a walk-in shower is the smarter choice.
Homebuyers often prefer at least one bathtub in a home, especially families with young children who need a tub for bathing. If selling your home is on the horizon, keeping or adding a bathtub could make your property more appealing. However, if your bathroom remodel is about optimizing for personal convenience rather than resale value, a sleek, modern walk-in shower might be the better investment.
If relaxation is a top priority, a bathtub is the clear winner. Soaking tubs, especially deep freestanding or jetted models, provide a spa-like experience at home. Walk-in showers, however, can also be upgraded for a high-end feel with features like rainfall showerheads, steam options, and multiple body sprays.
Walk-in showers and bathtubs vary in cost based on materials, size, and labor. A basic walk-in shower installation can range from $3,500 to $7,000, while a bathtub installation typically falls between $2,500 and $8,000. Custom tile work, high-end fixtures, or luxury soaking tubs can drive up costs. Consider both the upfront investment and long-term maintenance when budgeting for your remodel.
The choice between a walk-in shower or a bathtub depends on your lifestyle, space, and future plans. If accessibility, easy maintenance, and modern design are priorities, a walk-in shower may be the best fit. If you love long, relaxing baths or have young children, a bathtub might be the better option. Not sure which one suits your needs best? Contact Advantage Contracting for expert guidance and a customized bathroom renovation plan!